Sign up now!
Don't show this again
Download the report!Continue to Site >
or wait 7 secs

Thank you for confirming your subscription!

(And remember, if ever you want to change your email preferences or unsubscribe, just click on the links at the bottom of any email.)

We’re glad you’re enjoying Pig Health Today.
Access is free but you’ll need to register to view more content.
Already registered? Sign In
Tap to download the app


Collect articles and features into your own report to read later, print or share with others

Create a New Report


Read Later

Create a new report

Report title (required) Brief description (optional)
follow us

You must be logged in to edit your profile.

Favorites Read Later My Reports PHT Special Reports
Pig Health Today is equipped with some amazing (and free) tools for organizing and sharing content, as well as creating your own magazines and special reports. To access them, please register today.
Sponsored by Zoetis

Pig Health Today | Sponsored by Zoetis

Featured Video Play Icon

Connor: No clear winner in pen- versus crate-gestation debate

Sow housing during gestation continues to draw debate as some hog operations make a switch from crates to pens for gestation. The results are mixed, according to Joe Connor, DVM, Carthage Veterinary Service.

“We’re seeing a slow trend toward open-pen housing, driven by requirements of some individual states and also driven by the packers linked to consumers asking for open-pen housing of sows,” Connor told Pig Health Today.

Higher rate of mortality

While sows are free to move around in pen housing, this creates other welfare issues for gestating sows that do not occur in crates.

“As I look at our internal data as well as our external client data, generally what we see is that mortality is higher in pen gestation compared to stall gestation,” Connor said. “The difference is between 2% to 3% on an annual basis.

“That difference in mortality is made up in injuries, fighting or interactions that those sows have with each other, and an increase of prolapses at the end of pregnancy.”

Different pen designs help reduce sow fighting. Connor said units with pens and access to individual crates work better.

“In open-pen housing where we have stalls that they can come and go in, frequently…90% to 95% of the sows will be within the stalls,” he said. “It appears that their own decision, frequently, is to have that safety.”

In early pregnancy, Connor supports keeping sows in crates to prevent losses during implantation, which can occur when sows fight. “There is an advantage in terms of fertility,” he said. “The sows can be heat-checked, real-time ultrasound, and then put into pens from 35 days of pregnancy to the end.”

Gestation changes inevitable

Connor believes that the industry, driven in part by the movement in Europe to pen gestation, will need to make changes. But he sees the US finding ways to accommodate their own production system. This means coming up with new ways or new equipment to better manage gestation.

“No matter what stage we mix those animals…there’s going to be a period of social interaction and fighting,” Connor said. “As an example, there may be a need for toys and interaction within those pens and facilities.”

Connor doesn’t see the industry going back to straw. Biosecurity issues with bedding will prevent its widespread use. Plus, current manure-handling systems don’t work with bedding materials.

Electronic sow feeding in pens has solved the problem of feeding sows based on body condition or stage of gestation. No doubt other issues with gestation will be solved, too.

“We’ll have a slow transition but hopefully still a choice. Does the producer want to continue to use stalls? Or does he want to move to a combination of stalls plus pens over the next 5 years?” he concluded.


Posted on January 22, 2019

tags: ,

You must be logged in to edit your profile.

Share It
It’s not unrealistic to say that if you checked the nasal cavities or tonsils of any group of pigs, you would find Strep suis. While the strain and impact can vary widely, this commensal bacterium is on virtually every hog farm.

Click an icon to share this information with your industry contacts.
Google Translate is provided on this website as a reference tool. However, Poultry Health Today and its sponsor and affiliates do not guarantee in any way the accuracy of the translated content and are not responsible for any event resulting from the use of the translation provided by Google. By choosing a language other than English from the Google Translate menu, the user agrees to withhold all liability and/or damage that may occur to the user by depending on or using the translation by Google.